Friday, July 29, 2016

Understanding Racism

First of all, Defining Race
The first thing you should know is that race is not a scientific term. It is used in biology, but informally, and there is a lot of debate as to how to define race in the animal kingdom. Some scientists distinguish races based on small differences in chromosomes, or geography, or physiology (what the animals look like). None of this is based on any rigid scientific rules.
So, race is not science, it's a social construct, meaning it's a way for people to categorize things, to make the world simpler and easier to understand. The problem is people don't all fit into neat little categories, and the world isn't simple. So thinking in terms of race is problematic. It can mislead you.
 
Defining Racism
Racism comes in many forms, so it's hard to pin down one definition. And yet, so many people try to do that, demanding that we narrow the debate to one specific form, such as public displays of racism: name-calling, police brutality, church burnings. As soon as we do this, we can wait for stories to go away, and then people can pretend it doesn't exist. Political pundit Ann Coulter even went so far as to claim racism is dead! America has a black president––problem solved!
As soon as you question the definition, people get mad. They'll tell you to open a dictionary, not realizing that dictionaries have multiple definitions of many words, including racism. See for yourself:
 
1. The belief that each race has distinct and intrinsic attributes (This seeing in terms of race is tricky, because it can actually be true in some cases––statistically, blacks are less likely to develop skin cancer. The problem lies not in acknowledging differences, but in assuming them without evidence).
2. The belief that one race or group of races is superior or inferior to another (passive racism).
3. Prejudice or discrimination based upon race (active racism).
 
Prejudice Versus Discrimination
Prejudice is what you think of someone you haven't even met, while discrimination is what you do to this person, based on that prejudice. Prejudice is passive; discrimination is active.
However, prejudice isn't simply about racism, it's about judgement, and, often times, life confronts you with situations where you don't know all the facts, you can't know all the facts, and so you have to judge based on prejudice.
Think of a young woman walking alone at night. She sees a strange person coming toward her. He's dressed poorly, he's walking funny, possibly drunk. He looks dirty, unshaven, crusty. His eyes are bloodshot. Maybe his forehead is bleeding. He's talking to himself, and he laughs a bit like a hyena. Nature and evolution have bred us to notice these cues and make predictions about this man's behaviour and potential threat. This is normal and quite healthy. We know the man could be the sweetest person, respectable even, but it's still wise for the girl to avoid him, unless of course he's in serious need of medical attention, in which case she should call an ambulance, but still avoid him (unless she's bigger and stronger, trained in karate, etc. But still, you want to avoid confrontation is what I'm saying).
This is the kind of situation we must all judge for ourselves, but we must also realize that our predictions and prejudice may be wrong. And we must consider whether our judgments are affected by race.
Most importantly, we must recognize the difference between this kind of threatening personal situation in which we prejudge one person whom we can see and observe, versus a debate about public policy, where there is no immediate threat, and a speaker chooses to prejudge an entire population that he probably don't see because of segregation and gentrification.
 
Different Kinds of Racism
 
Overt
This is loud, public, honest racism. There's nothing hidden here. Examples include hate groups like the Ku Klux Klan dressing in white hoods and burning crosses on black people's lawns. Any time someone shouts the 'N' word, that's overt racism. Any time someone repeats a stereotype or tells a racist joke, that's overt racism.
 
Institutional
This is racism found in large organizations, including governments, businesses, banks, etc. It can be overt or covert. When the American South set up "Jim Crow" laws, segregating towns and public spaces into black and white areas, that was overt institutional racism. Police could arrest black people for entering a "white's only" restaurant, restroom, or shop. It was finally outlawed in 1965.
But, segregation still exists today in America, and you’ll find it at most American neighbourhoods and schools. There's no law enforcing it, but there are institutions, like failing schools, that perpetuate it, creating poor, dangerous ghettos that minorities can’t escape from. They don't have the money to move out, and for many decades, those who did have money were not allowed to move into all-white neighbourhoods. The second minorities did enter a neighbourhood, it would experience "white flight" as white people moved away, lowering the property values.
Now, the opposite situation is occurring. Some businesses are investing in poor, downtown areas of cities, creating new office buildings and businesses that attract wealthier, educated workers. What used to be a ghetto becomes "gentrified." With gentrification, the poor are kicked out. Their homes are renovated, and wealthier people move in, erasing a great deal of the culture and diversity that had been present for generations.
Racial profiling is another overt institutional form of racism that exists today, practiced by police in the US. Under this policy, police may stop and search citizens based on their race, who are not suspects of a crime, and check for weapons and drugs. This is normally illegal in the US, but some cities have embraced it as a way to lower crime.
 
Economic
If you look at about any statistic in the US regarding race, you'll find that black people get paid less for the same work, are promoted less, and are the last hired and first fired. They're less likely to go to college, and much more likely to go to prison. And it's not because blacks commit more crime. Blacks are treated differently. Many urban, poor communities have different attitudes to police in schools and arresting children as if they were adults. Getting a criminal record at an early age for school fights, trying drugs, etc, can ruin a teen's chances for college and a career. According to NPR (2014), it starts as early as 4 years old - 18% of black preschoolers are suspended nearly 50% of the time. While boys are more likely to be suspended than girls, black girls (12%) are twice as likely to be suspended as white boys (6%).
Every so often you'll see on the news, an experiment where real estate agents tour a house and estimate its value. When the homeowners are white (they're really actors) the estimate is always higher than when they are black, even though they pretend to live in the same house, have the same jobs, even the same clothes. And when similar actors go to a bank asking for a loan (presenting the same credentials), who do you think gets the better deal? These tests show that minorities have a harder time earning and gaining wealth.
 
Cultural
In academia, cultural racism is defined as when one culture considers itself superior to various minority groups around it, for example antiziganism against Roma.
But, cultural racism also involves denying minorities a voice. Hollywood is a big example. Minorities are often type cast as criminals and villains, or as a token black friend. When a minority character is portrayed as a hero, he or she is often played by a white actor wearing makeup (this is known as “whitewashing”). And whites win the majority of awards each year. Meanwhile, the US TV news often describes local crimes in detail, emphasizing black suspects.
Native Americans, Africans, and Asians are denied wall space in most museums and galleries, but are often portrayed in "orientalist" art as stereotypes - the noble savage, the slave for sale, the desert nomad. These cultures are portrayed as archaic, weak, traditional, and romantic. The brushwork is realistic, but that's where the realism ends.
Another aspect to cultural racism is in toys, where, for the last century, it's been hard to find many figures, dolls, and characters that represent different races and body types. Just this year, Barbie Dolls have finally been designed to look more realistic, coming in a variety of body types and skin colours, without being exotic princesses from foreign lands.
 
Colour Blindness
This is the belief that racism is no longer a serious issue. It's a popular sentiment that is often argued in the media. Some say the world has progressed a great deal since the 1960's, and so laws like affirmative action or voting rights laws are no longer necessary.
       In 2013, the Supreme Court repealed the Voting Rights Act of 1965, which had ensured the right to vote for all citizens. The court argued it was no longer necessary. Within hours of the decision, several states passed new "voter ID" laws that would make it harder for blacks and other minorities to vote. The idea behind these laws is to demand a photo ID from people who are already registered to vote--they think they've done everything they need to vote, but then they can't. And these laws also make it hard to get a photo ID in time for the election. For example, in Sauk County, Wisconsin, their State Photo ID office is only open 4 days a year.
       And while politicians argue this is to prevent voter fraud, these laws do nothing to prevent vote buying, tampering, and ballot box stuffing. All these do is prevent voter impersonation, which is not a problem. No one wants to stand in line for hours just to vote twice, or three times--it would make no difference in an election. And, several politicians have admitted that the purpose of these laws is to prevent enough minorities from voting so that a Republican candidate can win over a Democrat. So, the idea that America has progressed into a truly colour-blind meritocracy is false.

Affirmative Action
In the 1950's, many schools and colleges in the US refused to accept black applicants. They were white-only schools. The Supreme Court eventually ruled in favour of "affirmative action" requiring a certain percent of minorities to be accepted in every school in the nation each year. These same quotas were then introduced into large businesses and factories to ensure that at least some minorities would be promoted to managerial positions.
Opponents today claim that these practices lead to unqualified and incompetent students and employees, and that only the best candidates should ever be accepted. They say the world today is much more progressive, so minorities will not be rejected merely for their skin colour. They say it's condescending to think that minorities can't get in to university or get a job without lowering their standards.
And yet, there's no evidence that affirmative action leads to lower standards - this is just assumed. And, the fact that minority students are more likely to drop out of university has more to do with the fact that they're poorer, and that the schools accept academically weak students for college athletics (schools make a ton of money from sports like football and basketball).
Opponents argue that university admissions should be meritocratic, while ignoring a host of admissions policies that aren't meritocratic at all. For example, most universities are obligated to accept a certain percentage of in-state applicants, and those students pay a smaller tuition fee. Out-of-state applicants face a smaller chance of acceptance, and have to pay much more. Furthermore, the children of alumni get a bonus to their chance of admission, especially if their parents give the school money on a regular basis. Even if an applicant has no alumni in his family, they can give a large monetary gift and still get the child in.
 
The Psychology of Racism
A good way to think of racism is like a psychological disorder, with a spectrum of different symptoms and manifestations. There are levels of racism, like a sliding scale of evil. People can be racist for different reasons, depending on differing personalities and experiences. Some might seek to avoid speaking with or knowing minorities, while others may actively seek out minorities and persecute them. Some might express fear of minorities because of all those TV reports about black criminals. Some might express anger at affirmative action, blaming it for not getting into the school of their choice, seeing only how it affects them, and not the larger picture. Some might find a different skin colour to be repulsive, refusing to consider dating anyone of that colour or ethnicity. Internet dating networks today show that Asian men and black women are the two least attractive race-and-gender combinations on any network, and have the hardest times finding a partner. And then, there are those who are paranoid enough to believe in conspiracies and doomsday scenarios, and feel the need to band together into hate groups. Some feel so strongly, they are willing to hurt, kill, and burn churches of minorities in order to “keep these people in their place.”
 
Emotional Impact of Racism
Life as a member of the minority is challenging. Fear is ever present. Speaker Clint Smith recalls how his father lectured him, when he was a boy, "You can't act the same as your white friends. You can't pretend to shoot guns. You can't run around in the dark. You can't hide behind anything other than your own teeth." This was after he'd played in a hotel parking lot with squirt guns. In America, all black children grow up in this environment––don’t move too quickly, keep your hands where people can see them, keep your hood down at night. Don't do anything at all to alarm police, or shopkeepers, or teachers, or you might get in trouble. You might get shot.
Comedian DL Hughley recalls the first time he was called the 'N' word. He was about eight years old, on a school field trip, and he wanted to buy some ice cream at a shop in Los Angeles. The shop clerk told him they didn't serve N–––––. Most children remember their birthday or their best Christmas gift, or their first football game. We need to remember that many minority children also remember their first experience with racism, just as vividly, and it creates a scar that people have to carry with them the rest of their lives.
 
White Flight & Whitopia
Whitopia, as defined by journalist Rich Benjamin, is any town or county that is charming, growing in population by more than 6% a year, of which over 90% of that growth is white. These places are the ultimate destination for "white flight," where white people leave ethnically diverse areas in search of some place better, meaning affluent, clean, natural, friendly, and safe. Guns are very popular here, as is church and rebel flags. Not everyone here is a racist, but racist groups such as the Aryan Nation do meet here.
What causes white flight? Benjamin says it's a question of conscious and unconscious bias - pushes and pulls. People don't all go to Whitopia for racist reasons, but it has racist outcomes. "The danger of Whitopia is that, the more segregation we have, the less we can look at and confront conscious and unconscious bias." People don't have to think about racism. It becomes abstract and theoretical, not an every day experience.
Why don't black people go to Whitopia? First of all, most black Americans can't afford it. Second, most don't feel welcome. When you're the only black man in St. George, Utah, or Coeur D'Alene, Idaho, you feel exotic and strange. Rich Benjamin did it, for two years, and was says he was accepted in each and every community. He says, "It's a devastating irony, how we have gone forward as individuals, and backwards as communities." Rich wants us to question and reject that notion that “One black man is a delightful dinner guest, fifty black men is a ghetto.”
 
The Rebel Flag
This was the flag of the Confederate States of America, who fought the United States from 1860-1863 over the right to own slaves. They believed that blacks were inferior to whites and that the mistreatment of blacks was justifiable. Although the Confederacy lost, many southerners have displayed this flag in their homes, on their cars, and in their towns as a form of intimidation of blacks. Starting around 1961, many southern states decided to fly the flag in their capitols as a scare tactic, during the Civil Rights movement. These states argued it was a proud part of their history and heritage, while in reality, it was a reaction to blacks like Martin Luther King Jr. demanding an end to Jim Crow laws. As these flags have finally started coming down from state capitols, comedian Larry Wilmore asks, "If we flew every flag from our past, why aren't we flying the Union Jack at the White House?" Meanwhile, many neo-nazi groups in Europe use the rebel flag in place of the swastika, which is illegal in much of Europe. This issue has been further clouded by use of the flag to symbolize any and all forms of rebellion and southern pride, for example in the TV show Dukes of Hazard, in which two criminal heroes drive a car with a large flag painted on the roof. But Larry Wilmore astutely points out that the meaning of the flag is far too tainted with racism and hate to be able to express anything innocent or friendly.
 
Combating Racism
One thing we all can do is to point out racism when we see it. Don’t keep quiet, because racism thrives in silence. But, remember the difference between what someone says or does, and what they are. You can and should point out when someone says something racist. That's something you can prove logically. What you can't really do is prove that someone's intentions are racist, or that deep down, they're a racist. Hold people accountable for what they do and say, but be ready to explain why what they said was racist, and be prepared to acknowledge that their intentions may have been innocent.
Another thing we can do is to document racism when we see it, with photos, videos, and film. America's recent movement, Black Lives Matter, got going thanks to smart phones that recorded violent acts against blacks.

No comments:

Post a Comment